I hadn’t planned on posting anymore here, because I don’t really consider myself part of the fandom anymore, but I am not “scared” to express my views, and I do not ever hide behind anonymous posts or alt accounts.
I have interacted with Mixmaster a few times. And while I do agree with his general sentiment, I think his methods are a complete waste of time, and we strongly disagree on a lot of details (especially tagging random people in tweets). My attitude now, is basically the result of over 2.5 years of people telling me I can’t disregard S9 because “it’s canon”. I don’t CARE what Hasbro says “canon” is. My patience for people saying dumb things like that was exhausted over 2 years ago, and I will not put up with it. I do not consider S9 canon (except for 3 early episodes which is neither here nor there), and I do not accept the ending. I don’t care what other people like or don’t like, I’m just tired of people telling ME that I have to accept it, because I will not, and they can’t make me. That’s not referring to any specific individual, just “in general”. I left the “general fandom” because it no longer shares my interests - to put it bluntly, they are not fans of the same thing I am, so there is no common ground for me to be part of that community anymore.
There is this “argument” going around that people don’t like the ending because “it doesn’t match their headcanon”. That’s a strawman. None of us EVER said that (not even Mixmaster), and headcanon has nothing to do with it. I (and even Mixmaster, this is one thing we do agree on) want the ending to be true to the characters and the world. The “ending” given is not. It is OOC, they had to twist everyone into bad caricatures of themselves to make what passes for a story work. Everyone was character assassinated, and even details of the world contradict what we know. But that is just one point, I could easily write a novel about all the problems, but I don’t feel like writing a novel here. That doesn’t mean the points I’m NOT addressing here aren’t important.
I can, and have, spoken reasonably about what’s wrong with the season in general, and this episode in particular, in the past. And if there is anyone who is genuinely curious about my views, I don’t mind explaining it. It has nothing to do with “my headcanon”, just what makes sense for the characters/world. What I AM tired of is Hasbro apologists telling me “you MUST accept it because it’s canon”. I have heard that many times, and I am sick of it, and I am not going to be cordial to those people. The splinter group I am part of (which is steadily growing) is NOT SaveMLP. In fact SaveMLP and I have strong disagreements on a lot of things (even if we have the same basic sentiment about the “ending”). We have no intention of trying to “force” Hasbro to do anything (we think it is a complete waste of time). Hasbro is a corporation and everything they do is based on money. Our long term goal is to rewrite it ourselves. I’ve written a few outlines to fix a few episodes. I wrote a new outline for 2,4,6,Great in less than 2 minutes that makes it actually in character for Rainbow. (Note: an outline is NOT a complete script, it’s just a general outline.) The ending will have to be completely different. IN THE PRESENT (no stupid time skip plot devices), with a general “and the adventure continues” vibe. That way, anyone can imagine whatever they want. Progress on this is slow of course, but with creative video editing and some 15.ai voices we may eventually have something substantial beyond writing.
I do not hide behind anonymous posts, and I make no attempt to hide any of my views. I also don’t care what people think. But as I said, if someone is genuinely interested in my views on why the season is so bad, I don’t mind sharing them.
I have no idea where the discussion of fascists came from a couple pages back, I can only assume that’s another discussion entirely that happens to be in the same thread. I am STRONGLY against fascism in all forms, and I actively fight against it.