Rating tags general

Rating check:
>>2250148 is currently questionable, should it be explicit instead?

>>2556541 is currently questionable, is it indeed showing “Moderately-detailed genital or anus outlines in clothing” or does it reach explicit-level?
Same question: >>3015863

Isn’t a sex toy, such as a dildo, not in use not automatically explicit? For example, should >>3289822 (currently explicit) be rated down to questionable?

@Background Pony #4230
First one seems Questionable, second and third seem Explicit, but I’ll have to check further. Not sure about the last, detail on dildos can push them to Explicit.

>>3314194 was changed to Safe by staff, but is pretty aggressively Suggestive.

As per the Suggestive description “Sexually showing off part of the body or a situation with more than just a saucy look, like presenting a butt or stroking a stuffed belly seductively “ and I think the camera being zoomed in on Fluttershy twerking at it clearly counts as “presenting a butt”.

@Princess Luna
Would you mind explaining to us how the image that Snicky refers to falls under “safe”?

.

@icicle wicicle 1517
Wrong thread.

@Background Pony #B065
Oh shit ur right lol

@Snicky
That part of the guidelines is about the character’s action, not the camera’s, zooming in on a butt is something done in FiM itself at times, but there’s no direct equivalent for the dancing motion. The image is currently under review.

If I’m not missing something, >>108063 would be safe or maybe semi-grimdark, definitely not explicit, right?

Requesting rating check for >>3061905. currently set to semi-grimdark, should it be grimdark instead?

Semi-grimdark description states “Minor physical/sexual abuse, including very dubious consent”. But since the original upload by one of the artists who worked on the animation, the game has been stated as tentacle rape porn.

Also not sure on the tags of dubious consent and dubious consentacles. While the tentacles don’t visibly maim Applejack, they clearly aren’t being gentle on her and her visual discomfort lasts throughout the entire animation

>>3334809
Explicit due to the inherent implication of secretions or leave as-is?

@Background Pony #4230
Right.

@Background Pony #BC65
Just them calling it that doesn’t really matter for ratings, only how things look in the end result.

@Brokedownandmadeone
Secretions are a difficult one when they’re from a sexual orifice but not sexual in nature, and they can just be at Suggestive.

>>3332596
Tags were changed again before tag lock but wasn’t sure if it was just dubious consent or proper rape. Feels like former with nervousness/fear but still looking like he wanted to and in the last panel seems like genuine desire for her to take her time. Currently has both along with spikeabuse, abuse.

@Brokedownandmadeone
Have you tried reporting the image and/or talking a staff member about the issue? 🤔