Some Pacifier Pone 
um???? lmao???
@WingbeatPony
That’s because almost nobody wants a “no fun allowed” site without the uniqueness.
That’s because almost nobody wants a “no fun allowed” site without the uniqueness.
[NSFW][PROPOSAL] Standardizing the Character-Breast Tags
Scrabbleman 
[screams in German]
@Pacific Glow
Please stop bringing up the “no fun allowed” argument.
Nobody is trying to stop people from having fun, stop thinking that people are against fun, it’s just a tag and no one’s life depends in it, and the “no fun allowed” argument isn’t even an argument. It’s a complaint without any basis. If this was an actual court and office, people would’ve just ignored it.
It’s a tag, for God’s sake. We’re not even removing it!
Please stop bringing up the “no fun allowed” argument.
Nobody is trying to stop people from having fun, stop thinking that people are against fun, it’s just a tag and no one’s life depends in it, and the “no fun allowed” argument isn’t even an argument. It’s a complaint without any basis. If this was an actual court and office, people would’ve just ignored it.
It’s a tag, for God’s sake. We’re not even removing it!
Exedrus 
@Pacific Glow
Well, once people have mulled over the options and chosen their position, more discussion doesn’t often change minds. :I
@HJSDGCE
Pretty much. It’s not a simple matter of fun vs no fun. Some enjoy these puns and others would rather something else.
Well, once people have mulled over the options and chosen their position, more discussion doesn’t often change minds. :I
@HJSDGCE
Pretty much. It’s not a simple matter of fun vs no fun. Some enjoy these puns and others would rather something else.
BurningLance 
Lover of Huge Pony Boobs
i would rather have the puns since it was used longer than busty “character name” tags like Apple Bloomed instead of Busty Apple Bloom
The Green Meanie
So I’m going to go ahead and be the guy and do this thing in about a day or so (I can’t be arsed to do it right now because laziness), so we can lock this monster back in the closet where it belongs.
Weapon: Paddle
Alright we are seriously spinning our wheels talking about this topic, and frankly enough is enough. Here’s a few things to remember:
So I’m going to go ahead and be the guy and do this thing in about a day or so (I can’t be arsed to do it right now because laziness), so we can lock this monster back in the closet where it belongs.
Mildgyth 
Senior Moderator
Humata, Hukhta, Hvarshta
@The Green Meanie
I thought we had said this was going to be a test; if you were going to impose that change regardless of user reaction, then why even have this thread?
I thought we had said this was going to be a test; if you were going to impose that change regardless of user reaction, then why even have this thread?
The Green Meanie
Weapon: Paddle
@Mildgyth
We’ve gotten 15 days worth of input from this thread, but it’s just not going anywhere. Since the change is cosmetic and can be reversed very easily if need be, I want to implement it and see what actually happens.
We’ve gotten 15 days worth of input from this thread, but it’s just not going anywhere. Since the change is cosmetic and can be reversed very easily if need be, I want to implement it and see what actually happens.
OneOverTwo 
Spinister
@Mildgyth
My first thought would be to judge by relation to head size, but I also realize that busty drawings with irregularly large heads are also a thing that’s drawn…
My first thought would be to judge by relation to head size, but I also realize that busty drawings with irregularly large heads are also a thing that’s drawn…
Lead Pie 
This is a box.
@The Green Meanie
-It’s not supposed to be a cosmetic change, I’ve been told that it’s ‘more convenient’. (Wow, they’re all under b now…)
-This is exactly the point I was repeating the whole time. I don’t search for the tags, I just happen to find them under images I’m looking up for other reasons.
-I guess the thread got too long because not everyone agreed with the change.
@HJSDGCE
But it’s about the site’s ways to handle these things. And changing the alias to the standard form might just be a decision that’s applied to other cases as well.
-It’s not supposed to be a cosmetic change, I’ve been told that it’s ‘more convenient’. (Wow, they’re all under b now…)
-This is exactly the point I was repeating the whole time. I don’t search for the tags, I just happen to find them under images I’m looking up for other reasons.
-I guess the thread got too long because not everyone agreed with the change.
@HJSDGCE
But it’s about the site’s ways to handle these things. And changing the alias to the standard form might just be a decision that’s applied to other cases as well.
Dsiak
Actual Horse
What if we organize the Tags by their main aliases, so that “raritits” for exemple would be organized in the list as if it where “busty rarity”, and we could still read the pun on the tag if the uploader used it.
or have pun appear in the tag on the image only, so you search for busty rarity but the tag displays “busty rarity (raritits)”
or have pun appear in the tag on the image only, so you search for busty rarity but the tag displays “busty rarity (raritits)”
Scrabbleman
[screams in German]
@Lead Pie
It’s still not the worst thing ever that ever happens on site. A tag change isn’t going to ruin the site for people.
Mods asked us to give our opinion and we did. That’s it. We don’t have to argue or counter other people’s opinions. This isn’t a debate.
We’re lucky that the mods even asked us. Sites like Google and Facebook change on a whim and see how people react. They could’ve gone through that route!
It’s still not the worst thing ever that ever happens on site. A tag change isn’t going to ruin the site for people.
Mods asked us to give our opinion and we did. That’s it. We don’t have to argue or counter other people’s opinions. This isn’t a debate.
We’re lucky that the mods even asked us. Sites like Google and Facebook change on a whim and see how people react. They could’ve gone through that route!
WingbeatPony 
Tag horse
Just to be clear: We are not yet setting this alias. As mentioned before, I’d like to see more suggestions about what we can further do to solve this problem, since a cosmetic change is not an adequate solution.
Mildgyth
Senior Moderator
Humata, Hukhta, Hvarshta
@WingbeatPony
Posting this now because i was asleep when all of that discussion before TGM’s post happened![full]()
1 - Please clarify.
2 - No. my opinion is already that these tags should be kept, and such a system would solve our problems of fiding such tags.
3 - None.
Posting this now because i was asleep when all of that discussion before TGM’s post happened
1 - Please clarify.
2 - No. my opinion is already that these tags should be kept, and such a system would solve our problems of fiding such tags.
3 - None.
LightningBolt 
Senior Moderator
Undead inside
@WingbeatPony
And do explain why we’re not, don’t just say that we’re not and not give details.
And do explain why we’re not, don’t just say that we’re not and not give details.
Lead Pie
This is a box.
@WingbeatPony
I’ve been thinking about other solutions as well, but most approaches would probably make things just much more complicated.
Maybe a tag wiki (similar to tags having descriptions) where you could search not just for tags, but also see related tags and search for specific words in their description. (Like I’d be able to search for ‘breasts’ and could find the busty*/pun tags.)
Or just a function where you could maybe have another search field on the ‘tags’ page which searches tag descriptions instead of tags themselves.
I’ve been thinking about other solutions as well, but most approaches would probably make things just much more complicated.
Maybe a tag wiki (similar to tags having descriptions) where you could search not just for tags, but also see related tags and search for specific words in their description. (Like I’d be able to search for ‘breasts’ and could find the busty*/pun tags.)
Or just a function where you could maybe have another search field on the ‘tags’ page which searches tag descriptions instead of tags themselves.
Exedrus
@WingbeatPony
>I’ve been looking at the suggestions for how to make these tags more convenient…
Shouldn’t this be it’s own thread? Proposing something to categorize tags to make search easier would affect the focus of this thread, but also greatly widens its scope… I mean no one is going to come to the tagging forum and think the thread titled “[NSFW][PROPOSAL] Standardizing the Character-Breast Tags” is where the discussion of some sort of tag searching/categorization scheme would be taking place.
@WingbeatPony
>…since a cosmetic change is not an adequate solution.
But wasn’t the cosmetic change all this thread was about?
>I’ve been looking at the suggestions for how to make these tags more convenient…
Shouldn’t this be it’s own thread? Proposing something to categorize tags to make search easier would affect the focus of this thread, but also greatly widens its scope… I mean no one is going to come to the tagging forum and think the thread titled “[NSFW][PROPOSAL] Standardizing the Character-Breast Tags” is where the discussion of some sort of tag searching/categorization scheme would be taking place.
@WingbeatPony
>…since a cosmetic change is not an adequate solution.
But wasn’t the cosmetic change all this thread was about?
Background Pony #37C7
oh i dunno how long the ‘‘test’’ gonna last (if a test is going on) but i think many wants the pun as the main tag that shows up when searching while the Busty “character name” is in the alias.
would have been much easier to keep it that way and it would (at least it think) cut down on the back and forth discussion thats going on now. (and possibly more in the future)
would have been much easier to keep it that way and it would (at least it think) cut down on the back and forth discussion thats going on now. (and possibly more in the future)
Background Pony #37C7
dang it forgot something.
also i see both apple bloom and applejack got the busty apple bloom and busty applejack as tag instead of apple bloomed and applerack which is in the alias atm.
oh i dunno how long the ‘‘test’’ gonna last (if a test is going on) but i think many wants the pun as the main tag that shows up when searching while the Busty “character name” is in the alias.would have been much easier to keep it that way and it would (at least it think) cut down on the back and forth discussion thats going on now. (and possibly more in the future)
dang it forgot something.
also i see both apple bloom and applejack got the busty apple bloom and busty applejack as tag instead of apple bloomed and applerack which is in the alias atm.
Wesley Foxx
The Fluffiest
Question. Do aliases work sufficiently that even if the pun names are the main tag, searching “Busty *” would still return all of the utility names?
Zeb 
Tag-Bot
@Keith Mowz
To quote the very first post in the thread:
To quote the very first post in the thread:
3: Due to Aliasing, you will still be able to search-by, or filter the tags by the old names: Since we would be aliasing the breast-tags into the standard format, you do not need to worry about your filters being affected. And you will also still be able to tag and search by the old names if you preferred that method. The only change will be in the tag displayed under the image itself.
[Note]: We currently have created the standardized tags, and have aliased them into the pun tags. Which you will be able to see if you look at some of the tags linked above. So you can see how the alias system operates directly when typing out tag names if you wish.
Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!
This topic has been locked to new posts from non-moderators.
Locked
Lock reason: Discussion complete