I like both.

I don’t think there’s that much difference between them. Switch between them based on how much you like the image you’re working on. If you really like it, add the extra detail. If not, just leave it at the simpler one.

@P3FOYFN  
lol that’s the first impression I got from opening this up the first time. xD

I think I prefer the right one, all for that cuddly fuzzy fur.

left is way better

I prefer the left, but the detail of the right may be better when there is everything else is detailed too.

Both are fantastic, use whichever seems most appropriate for the piece

This is all I can think of:
 

left

I love both styles. I think it really depends on the picture which one fits more.

Realistic Style Version all the way for me, Tsitra360. =)

I think either one works. The left one because it’s adorable and similar to the show. I also love the straight lines and the pointed ear. The right one because she looks so fuzzy!

If I have to be honest, I choose the one on the left.

Eh, I’d probably prefer the realism side. It’s hard to pass up all those fancy details if you’re gonna offer them. :D

I have to agree with @FanOfMostEverything, both are good, but what style is good depends on what you make. :)

Both. It really depends on which one you feel is more suited to the content of the image. Or feel like using.

The detailed style is really nice but I’m gunna go with cartoony style because I prefer the nice clean look it has.

Don’t make me choose Tsitra ;_;

Her eye looks partially blind on the cartoony side of things.Honestly this face doesn’t really fill me with any strong emotion towards either. Nothing stands out enough to say one way or another.
 
Going by your past works I have to say I enjoy the cartoony ones. Your art style is the same either way, so really it’s juts a matter of preference. Many like the 3D stuff more but just as many love the cuter and softer colors of the more cartoony look.
 
Besides, not much Diamond Tiara to judge realistic vs cartoony so I’ll just go with “Whatever works best for you” since I just prefer cute and interesting artwork and your two versions provide those from time to time in equal measure.

Both look good to me.

@Itsthinking  
Exactly, both look fabulous.

Twily <3

@Tsitra360  
Fixed. By the way, I like both! Both of them look good, just draw whatever you want.

Please include the original description when uploading to image boards. The purpose of this drawing was to present a question.  
“Which side you prefer? Cartoony/Comic on the left, or Realistic/Detailed on the right?”